Campfires, Conversations And The Midterms
The following post was originally published on Medium.com at the beginning of 2024, a presidential election year. While we aren’t electing a President this year, it is still relevant for the midterm election season we find ourselves in now.
As I write, we are two weeks into the new year of 2024. It still has that ‘New Car’ smell to it. It’s a new beginning and a fresh start.
Everybody To Their Corners!
2024 is an election year, which usually sends everyone to their respective corners, ready to defend their positions to the death. We all know what we believe and why we think it’s the only way to think. We are prepared to show the world we’re right and why they’re wrong.
Even now, I sense some readers gauging which side I fight for, to ready their defenses, or to happily encourage me with reinforcements.
Easy now. I come bearing gifts. Lay down your arms and arguments.
What I want to suggest is a non-confrontational meeting of the minds. This will appeal to the intellectual that’s pretty certain he or she is right about their position, as well as the knucklehead who knows he’s right and won’t consider anything else.
It also reaches out to the regular schmoe who is trying to make it through this complicated world, unsure but trying to figure it out as he goes.
An Unlikely Solution To A Common Problem
Are you ready for this nugget of brilliance? I won’t keep you in suspense.
It’s a campfire.Yes. A regular burning of sticks and logs on a chilly night. The smell of smoke. The sound of crackling seasoned firewood. The occasional pop that blows out sparks indiscriminately. The purr of a fire gaining momentum as it draws in strength from the air around it.

The wind shifts and smoke chokes you until you change your spot as though it’s a divine game of musical chairs. If the temperature is low enough, you may even have to turn to warm opposite sides of your body to stay comfy, as though you were a rotisserie bird that needs heat to all sides.
Yes.
That simple solution is my offering. How would that solve any political divide? What’s the point of a fire? Important issues are hammered out in Congress, not around a pit like cavemen. I can hear the resistance already.
I get it. Let me finish.
A Campfire Has A Way Of Humbling Us
Something magical happens when people are in the silence of nature. They feel the wind blow, they notice the stars revealing themselves, and become aware of the moon casting shadows around them.
Being in the outdoors helps human beings realize they’re a part of a larger story. It’s a pretty big planet. There’s lots of us out here. One person’s agenda or passion shouldn’t go to the front of the line before everything else. Shouting the loudest shouldn’t silence the quieter voices.
Of course people are valuable and their thoughts important, but not the ‘be all and end all’ of everything. It’s a paradigm shift. Sorry if that hurts.
It’s humbling.
But it’s okay because there is truth in seeing the role we play in the big picture. Around a campfire, the silence between words spoken is more natural and less awkward. It offers the hearers time to ponder it, mull it over and consider a response, or if there should be a response at all.
My experience has been that people are more relaxed and therefore more inclined to share around the safety of a warm fire. It draws out the ones usually reluctant to share. It tempers the bloviators.
The solitude and quietness of a campfire enable the guards to go down. It levels the playing field with perspectives and opinions.I heard someone say recently that America is the most divided nation on the planet and wondered why that was true.
Listening Doesn't Mean Agreeing
I believe it’s because the media and the politicians benefit when you take a side, hopefully their side. What if you refuse to? What if you listen to your neighbor who thinks differently? What if you hear an opposing opinion, and learn you won’t die instantly? What if you promise yourself to hear someone you disagree with? It’s not a commitment to agree but to listen.
A conversation is a dialogue, not a monologue. That's why there are so few good conversations: due to scarcity, two intelligent talkers seldom meet.
— Truman Capote
You are NOT betraying your convictions by keeping your mouth closed and hearing another speak. This is how free people govern themselves. Debate and controversy are not bad things. It’s working important things out. Listening is better than shouting down. Making a counterpoint beats name calling.
The Lost Art Of Civil Disagreement
I call for the return of the lost art of conversation. Real dialogue can expose weaknesses in our convictions. It makes us question ourselves about what we believe, and why we’re so certain about it. I’m always shocked when someone can’t explain their belief. Just because doesn’t carry the Debate Team award home.
But if someone has a bulleted list of reasons and can explain them, I'm all ears. They know their own mind and I want to hear it. If they do it without anger, I’m really impressed.
Cancel culture is hubris. It says in effect ‘Agree with me or else!’ Americans and freedoms we enjoy must be strong enough to live beside people who hold different views. It’s a great exercise for all of us. If we can’t defend our beliefs without profanity or name calling, maybe we aren’t as well versed and confident in our view as we thought.
A savvy citizenry should be suspicious of leaders or movements beckoning them to their cause. Ask tough questions. Follow the money. Question the narrative and the motives behind it.
America Is Not A Football Game
Unfortunately, instead of intelligently pondering the best way forward for our nation and what is truly best for us all, it has devolved into a team sport mentality.
Our guys are the best, and the other ones should be destroyed!
America is our collective home and not a football game. Scoring the point at any cost shouldn’t be the ultimate goal.
But people will advocate for bad things, not because they’re evil but because it’s the position their team has officially adopted. And loyalty demands they promote it as well, even if personally they have doubts.
This should stop.
Critical thinking helps it happen. Our loyalty should lie with our own principles, not the group's agenda.
Going back to the football analogy, who could celebrate a win for their team if it spelled the complete destruction of the league and the end of the sport?
The political arena needs the same logic applied. Perspective will change if we look at the long-term benefit as opposed to quick win or a Gotcha moment.
There's Room For Everyone. Pull Up A Chair
This is what happens when you sit around a campfire and talk honestly with other people. You learn things when you set aside prescribed solutions or pre-determined positions.
You receive ideas you never considered before. You relax. You choke on smoke and realize you are part of a wonderful population, which is less black and white, red and blue, cut and dried, gay and straight, rich and poor and different than the loudest voices wanted you to believe.
Build a campfire this weekend. Invite friends. Invite the weird neighbor. Buy adult beverages, or get some ‘smores. Sit around the warm flickering glow.
Listen and rediscover that we’re more alike than we are different.